A rebuttal (or response to reviewers) is your reply to the comments from the editor and reviewers. Copy the template below into your own document and fill in the parts in square brackets.

The colours help the editor see at a glance what is theirs and what is yours. Here, I used black for text copied from the editor or reviewers, blue for your response.

Add line numbers at the end

Line numbers change constantly while you’re editing, so don’t fill these in until you’ve definitely finished editing the document.

If you’ve rewritten some text, copy both the old and the new text so the reviewer can easily see what changes you’ve made. For the old text, use the line numbers from the old manuscript. For the new text, use the line numbers in the newest version.


Response to: comments from the editor(s) and reviewer(s)

Editor(s)

Response (about the decision) from the editor

We are pleased with the opportunity to improve the manuscript by making [minor/major] revisions.

[reply that you (we) are grateful for the (kind and thoughtful, if that applies) comments made by the reviewers.]

[address the general remarks made by the editor(s): what did you do to address those?] [for example: “Regarding the overarching comment highlighted by the editors, “comment”, we made the following adjustments:

  1. To address the issue of […], we have
    1. moved […] from the […] section to the Discussion (Section […], Lines […]-[…]), to emphasise […]
    2. […]
  2. […]

Reviewer 1

General response from the reviewer.

COMMENT

Reviewer comment

[explain how you addressed this comment]

OLD TEXT – Lines … - …: […]

NEW TEXT – Lines … - …: […]

ADDED TEXT – Lines … - …: […]

UPDATED FIGURE – Lines … - …: […]

COMMENT

Reviewer comment [explain how you addressed this comment]

For simple textual comments (for example: ‘L341: delete second ‘in’’), you can simply state ‘Done’ or ‘Adjusted’.

COMMENT

Reviewer comment [explain how you addressed this comment]

Reviewer 2

General response from the reviewer.

COMMENT

Reviewer comment [explain how you addressed this comment]

COMMENT

Reviewer comment] [explain how you addressed this comment]

Rebuttal letters can become extremely long

Sometimes even longer than the original manuscript, because every comment has to be addressed and clearly explained.